Fender FB-54 submitted 9/4/2008 Submitter shawnderailed (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased Chuck Levin's Music Year Purchased 2007 Price Paid Don't Remember historic exchange rates / currency converter Sound Mellower sound than most banjos. But sounds more "banjo like" whithout the resonator. Sound Rating 7 Setup I bought this already setup from the store. However, this banjo is easily upgraded and tweeked. However, with the guitar style tuners I'm conserned about how to put in Scruggs tuners. Setup Rating 8 Appearance I absolutly LOVE the look of the banjo. The staining is done nicely and the pearloid inlays are lovely. Appearance Rating 8 Reliability This is where this banjo shines. I've put my banjo through hell. Its been thrown off and on moving trains, been trecked through the rain while walking, and everything else possible. Most banjos I've encountered haven't survived this abuse, but this Fender has. I left it at a friends house for 6 months, then had it shipped across the country. When I got it back it was only slightly out of tune. Reliability Rating 10 Customer Service Customer Service not rated Components The bridge that came with it wittled away at the first string early on. The tailpeice is slightly warped, and the resinator stripped away at the connecting points to the rim. However, as I said I put this banjo through hell. Components Rating 9 Overall Comments I love this banjo and have gotten alot of compliments about it. I like the mellower sound compared to other banjos. I'd recommend this banjo to anyone who travels alot. Overall Rating 9

Bales Mahogany submitted 9/4/2008 Submitter Okinell (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased Bales Banjos Year Purchased 2008 Price Paid 3995.00 ($US) Sound First off I have yet to have a dislike. I know that everyone that owns his or hers banjo thinks their's is the best. But if your after that "growly" sort of loose pre-war Gibson sound your not going to find a better instrument.......period. The lower notes are powerful and the notes up the neck are just as sweet and bright at the 19th and 21st frets as they are down the neck. The sustain up and down the neck is well balanced, but doesn't over do it and get that obnoxious "ringing" some banjos do. Having played two other maple banjos I must admit I am sold forever on the rich, full, and much more balanced sound of mahogany. What I continually find amazing is how you can literally feel the resonance of sounds through the resonator and even into the neck. Sound Rating 10 Setup The banjo was setup by Ronnie Bales when I got it. The strings were lowered, of course, but Ronnie had marked the "sweet" spot for the bridge as he had played it in his shop. Ronnie is fanatical about his banjos and won't ship one until he feels the banjo has just about settled down for the most part. He sent my banjo with one of his bridges and as we have discussed at some length, it seems that at least on these mahogany instruments that bridges with fewer growth rings makes a considerable difference. The head was set up to roughly a G# that is right at 90 on the Drum Dial drum tuning instrument. I have had to re-tighten my head once so far to get a consistent reading on my Drum Dial and also had to move the bridge up about a 1/16 of an inch. The action is perfect for me and Ronnie really tries to work closely with you on that. He really is amazing how he can visualize just what your after, but continually reminds you that if it is not right to send it back and he will recut it, at NO CHARGE. The only thing that I warn you of is that he packs his banjos very carefully and just make sure to remove the resonator and remove ALL THE BUBBLE WRAP between the coordinating rods and the banjo head. Setup Rating 10 Appearance To say that this banjo is easy on the eyes would be a considerable understatement. The attention to deal and extreme craftsmanship is reflected in the flawless finish you will find. Ronnie cuts his own veneers for all of his resonators and only after studying the piece of wood for its greatest esthetics. The inlaying is precise and finished meticulously. About the only way to describe the depth you will find in his finishes is much like the if you've ever been to a crystal clear lake. If you've ever stared into the water from the shore of a sparkling clear lake with the sun shinning through it and that optical sensation of depth you realize is much the effect you get from the many coats of lacquer Ronnie insists on using Appearance Rating 10 Reliability All the hardware is from Prucha, unless you send your own. I sent him a full set of Keith D-Tuners, so that is the only difference on mine. Ronnie would use Keith tuners but has chosen another brand to try and keep his prices down, but will use what ever you want. The rest is all hand made by Ronnie Bales. I don't have the vocabulary to quite describe the increadible finish of his banjos. LIke I recently posted, Ronnie DOES NOT use fillers or sealers as these are all plastic. He uses all nitrocellose lacquers and it takes him days of spraying, sanding, and reapplying coat after coat of lacquer. This is the way any fine musical instrument should really be made. That is one of the reasons that the old Martins have gained such value. The lacquer is not just a protective coating, but is part of the actual instrument and has to conform, shrink and expand, and age along with the wood that the instrument was made from. This is one of the reasons that "nothing really does ring like a Bales". The staining he uses along with this lacquer creates a virtual depth in this mahogany that I have never seen before. Also finishes like this, if you do mar it can be repaired and buffed out usually with few issues or problems. `Most mass produced instruments use polyurethane and UV finishes that can be applied quickly and moved on out with little regard for the tonality. Its the "bottom line" their after, not sound. Reliability Rating 10 Customer Service Thesre instruments are guaranteed for life, or as long as Ronnie is around to service them. Ronnie and his wife Myra are two of the nicest folks you'll ever meet. You would think that they were lending out one of their kids when they sell you a banjo. He tells everyone, that he'll give you your money back if you don't like it. How can you argue with that? Customer Service 10 Components There is nothing that Ronnie puts on his banjos that he sells that he wouldn't or doesn't have on his own personal banjos. Ronnie was in the construction business for years before this and knows and appreciates quality parts, materials and workmanship. He personally goes out to small lumber mills and hand picks the wood he uses. Even then he will only cut and use the wood where the grain is right for what ever he is making at that time. Where most manufacturers could get 20 necks out of a board, Ronnie might get only 10 and then might cull even from that lot. He has now started working with Bill Blaylock on his own signature tone rings From the sounds of this first one there are going to be some sad faced over priced trendy tone ring owners. I personally have Blaylock Bear Tracks/J. D. Crowe ring .and wouldn't trade or change for anything, but I might get another Bales mahogony with Ronnie's signature ring. Components Rating 10 Overall Comments I would recommend any of the Bales banjos to anyone. I have told Ronnie that I really believe that there is going to be some banjo players looking in the mirror and wondering why they dropped 6 figures on an pre-war Gibson when they start hearing one of the Bales banjos. To say I would buy another Bales if mine were stolen is an understatement. I'm about to order my second one just in case....does that tell you something? The average price of a Bales right now is about $3995.00. To me that is unbelievable! What your buying is SOUND.........not a load of bobbles, bangles, glitz and glitter that does nothing unless your into "eye candy". Do yourself and your audience a favor and check out Bales Banjos............. Overall Rating 10

Ome Custom Bright Angel submitted 9/4/2008 Submitter jazzylynne (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased OME Year Purchased 2006 Price Paid Don't Remember historic exchange rates / currency converter Sound Bight but not too much. It sounds perfect, high highs and good lows. Sound Rating 10 Setup I have changed nothing. The banjo came out of the box sounding great. I am extremely happy with the sound and action of this banjo. Setup Rating 10 Appearance I had a special peg head put on the banjo. It is an open back peg head on a resonator banjo. This is the only one ever made. They also did a special stain for me, matching the stain I have another banjo. They made it a top tension adding not only to the looks but to the sound and feel of the banjo. Appearance Rating 10 Reliability Everything is still in top condition as I write this (2 years after I got it) The hardware is top notch. I have taken this banjo to a number of jams, it certainly holds it own. Reliability Rating 10 Customer Service No repairs have been needed and dealing with them when I ordered it was a pleasure. Customer Service 10 Components They have all of their metal parts made for them. All quality stuff. Components Rating 10 Overall Comments I would recommend this banjo for anyone well worth the price paid. Of all my banjos this is the one I will always keep. The only thing I would change now that I have tried one is a radiused fret board. Overall Rating 10

Williams Custom Banjos Kenny Ingram Model submitted 9/4/2008 Submitter OMB (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased Greg Boyd's House of Fine Instruments Year Purchased 2008 Price Paid 6,495.00 ($US) Sound Tight bottom end, perfect decay and yet a lingering sustain that just provides great note separation. Higher on the neck is just remarkable, bell tones, and believe it or not, have not touched the setup at all. Sound Rating 10 Setup Will Williams setup at G#, GHS Custom strings, 10,11,13,20,10, David Wadsworth bridge. Tone and setup, even after shipping was excellent. Would not change anything. Neck and string height were fine. Will is a master builder and the detail shows. Setup Rating 10 Appearance Steve Gill mahogany resonator, Handmade Arthur Hatfield neck. Excellent work and flying eagle inlay. Absolutely love the 'speed neck' option. Great feel. Super craftsmanship. Appearance Rating 10 Reliability Banjo was rock solid. Reliability Rating 10 Customer Service As with most small builders, no formal legal warranty. Just their word, which in this case is fine with me. This is #17 and they take immense pride in their work. Customer Service 10 Components I don't know what else to say here, but the best components. Starting with the Burlile tone ring, Sullivan 'old growth' old floor rim, Steve Gill Resonator, Handmade Arthur Hatfield Neck with Rosewood Fingerboard, nickel parts, Flying Eagle Inlay Pattern, RK Flange, Presto Tailpiece, David Wadsworth bridge, Bill Keith Tuners, Schaller 5th String tuner, Ivoroid Buttons, BHS Custom Strings, TKL Case w/ Williams monogrammed cover. Components Rating 10 Overall Comments What can you say? Great service on initial questions with Will Williams and Greg Boyd. Greg provides 72 hour approval period and he insists on making sure you really like what you purchase. Kenny Ingram plays and records with this banjo, so that pretty much says it all. I would highly recommend this banjo. Overall Rating 10

Gold Tone Bob Carlin BC-350 submitted 9/3/2008 Submitter Scanbran (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased Frailers (UK) Year Purchased 2008 Price Paid 659 (GBP) historic exchange rates / currency converter Sound I was upgrading from a very poor grade starter banjo, and from my favoured style of play, I was recommended a 'frailing banjo'. This Gold Tone BC-350 did not disappoint. A very loud sound for an open back banjo, but also slightly plunky for that old time tone. Sound Rating 9 Setup The banjo was selected by the shop tech as the best set up and most playable of the models available. It arrived with a very nice, playable action (not too low). I'm none to experienced with banjos so far, but it played like a dream right out of the box for me. Setup Rating 10 Appearance I love the look of this banjo - attractive blonde maple rim and neck, and beautiful striped ebony fretboard and headstock faceplate. The fretboard is not overelaborate with too much inlay work - instead it has simple MoP dot inlay fret markers, with a star inlay at the 5th fret, and a star motif on the headstock. I like the fact this banjo does not have the makers name emblazoned on the headstock - it's very understated and classy. Appearance Rating 9 Reliability It seems very solid and well put together. I've only had it a month, so it's hard to judge, but the top quality materials used suggest it will last just fine. Reliability Rating 9 Customer Service Frailers in Runcorn, UK were good to deal with. Helpful over the phone in making a selection, and very quick with delivery too. The banjo arrived in good order as described, with a hand written note from Dave asking me to call him if there was a problem. There was even a complimentary pack of strings in the case, in the event that any strings were broken in transit. I think the warranty is the standard Gold Tone Limited Lifetime, but I'm not sure. Customer Service 9 Components The fretboard is beautiful and the neck is easy to play being a little wider than normal. The flesh hoop was bent slightly, but makes no difference at all. The banjo was supposed to come with a Remo Rennaisance head, but instead has a Weatherking head. Don't really know the difference, and the Weatherking sounds great. Very good quality components as far as I can make out. Components Rating 8 Overall Comments I would certainly recommend this banjo for those looking for a frailing banjo with an old time sound, but not too soft and great volume levels if required. I paid a little too much, but the price included a top quality Gold Tone branded TKL hard case, specifically designed for a 12" pot and overnight shipping. So, looking at it that way, the banjo may only have cost me about £550. I love this banjo, and would definitely get another if it needed to be replaced. Overall Rating 9

Fitch Firestorm submitted 9/3/2008 Submitter zipposteve (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased FitchBanjos.Com Year Purchased 2008 Price Paid 4300.00 ($US) Sound I tried to be as specific as possible when telling Cliff Fitch the sound I was looking for. To summarize....I wanted a full, rich sound with lots of volume. I wanted a bright sound as well but without the thin, tinny, tone that usually comes with bright. There had to be excellent note separation and sparkle over the entire neck. The banjo that Cliff built for me has all of this plus an extraordinary response to the lightest touch. Sound Rating 10 Setup I let Cliff dtermine the setup that was necessary to produce the tone that I asked for. It's wonderful.... I wouldn't change a thing here. Setup Rating 10 Appearance Presentation grade flamed maple, gold hardware, antiqued binding on top of superlative craftsmanship ( Fit, Finish, & Detail Work). Add a Sunburst Finish that was done to my specs. I couldn't have asked for more. Appearance Rating 10 Reliability I've had enough high end instruments to know that this will never be an issue with a Fitch instrument. Reliability Rating 10 Customer Service There are many out there who could take a lesson from Cliff Fitch on customer service. He understands what a customer expects from a custom builder and delivers it in spades. There is no doubt in my mind that he will take care of me and my banjo in the years to come. Customer Service 10 Components In order to get the tone I wanted, Cliff used a Dannick ring, a Sullivan historic rim, and a Wadsworth bridge. I let Cliff suggest the components for what I wanted in sound. Components Rating 10 Overall Comments I wanted a banjo built just for me according to my specs. Cliff sent me pictures as the build progressed and made suggestions along the way. It was a great experience. I've spent a lot more & gotten a lot less. Overall Rating 10

Deering Calico Custom submitted 9/3/2008 Submitter DIV (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased Janet Davis Year Purchased 2008 Price Paid ($US) Sound This is a custom Calico. I ordered it with Brazilian Rosewood instead of maple and Tenbrooks pot instead of Deering 06. The tone is incredible. It has that richness and depth that I have come to appreciate in my Gibsons, but the Kruger tone ring adds an amazing purity that is VERY pleasing. This banjo is suited to all types of music depending on how you play it. Sound Rating 10 Setup Now I'm Obsessive compulsive about my set-up, but I didn't have do ANYTHING AT ALL. The set-up was perfeted by Janet Davis herself at Janet Davis Music. Nice and low action hieght, no buzzing or noises, perfectly even head tension. The only change I made was swapping out the SS bridge JDM place (to replace the stock Deering bridge) with one another "Mystery" bridge that I had and it was the perfect touch. Setup Rating 10 Appearance The super-rare Brazilian Rosewood they used is old growth lumber, not stump wood that is often used. The finish and polish is flawless. I choose to upgrade to Abalone inlays and I'm so glad I did so: very colorful. The inlays are completely flush with the ebony fingerboard which is extremely smooth and flawless. The binding, the fret finishing--all absolutely flawless. Appearance Rating 10 Reliability The hardware is nickel plated and I hope it develops a bit of tarnish, but right now it's all very brilliant. The finish is of the highest quality. Reliability Rating 10 Customer Service I've dealt with Deering on and off for over 10 years. They've always been there for me, even while I wasn't a Deering owner. My first resonator banjo was a used Deering Deluxe Custom and I was given lot's of support when I owned it. However, it did not need any service at all. My new Deering Calico has a lifetime warranty that only applies to the original owner which will always be me while I'm alive! Customer Service 10 Components The tuners are the smoothest around (I believe their customized Gotoh tuners). The tailpiece is the factory Deering model which is their improvement over the presto. The flange is the lighter-weight Tenbrooks version and the unplated Kruger tone ring is the culmination of the tone ring evolution as far as I'm concerned. It's cast in Switzerland by the Ruetschi foundry who's been casting and repairing bells and sculptures for over 600 years. Components Rating 10 Overall Comments I highly recommend Deering for you next banjo whether it's used, new or custom. Mine was a very personal combination of preferences and is thus my custom Calico is very unique. If it were stolen, I'd really be at a loss, both financially and emotionally. I am insuring it, but if were lost, I'd order another one, just like it. the wood species may have to be different however due to scarcity. Deering has vastly improved on their design and tone and this is largely due to by the development of their Tenbrooks tone system. Overall Rating 10

Epiphone MB-100 submitted 9/1/2008 Submitter duvidel (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased Guitar Center Year Purchased 2008 Price Paid 150.00 ($US) Sound It seems pretty bright and gives the Deering Goodtime competition for an affordable price. I am glad I got an open back instrument. Unfortunately, there were not enough banjo technicians at the store so I took it to Music Folk (www.musicfolk.com) for head tightening, nut repair, and bridge moving. I intend to have spikes added soon. It's great for Scruggs style picking and clawhammer alike. I will use either a Barcus-Berry discq or Dean Markley dot pickup with it. I intend to learn clawhammer. Sound Rating 10 Setup I could not afford a hard shell case at the store, went with an electric guitar gigbag, which suits my needs, but would rather have had a Superior (TM) banjo gig bag. I suggest buying one wherever you can. As for the setup, move the bridge toward the tailpiece, adjust the head tighter and the action lower. I would suggest the Barcus-Berry Discq (it's a dot pickup) because you can stick it on near the bridge and stick the plugin jack on the rim or run it outside a resonator to the body and stick it on. I give it a 9 simply because I had to go elsewhere for the setup and Guitar Center could not do it. Setup Rating 9 Appearance It is very plain and a light mahogany, no flaws. No custom work was done nor will be done. I do have a penchant for some wacky stickers on my gig bags though. :-) For instance, I would not use a Crybaby pedal with a banjo so stuck one on the gig bag. I am learning to leave things be and simple, to avoid inlay work. Appearance Rating 10 Reliability I believe overall it will be fine on its own. My only concern is that I believe it should have come with spikes for the price of the instrument, maybe $20.00 more for those added. The one thing I would change would be strap hooks or pegs independent of the brackets. That is a concern for durability, pulling too hard on the strap, etc. Reliability Rating 9 Customer Service I added a 2 yr warranty so Guitar Center is giving me 3 years (1 yr manufacturer's warranty). I wish it were lifetime or limited lifetime. Customer Service 9 Components I can't really answer, not knowing what to say. It is a great value for the money. It seems to have a very durable head. Components Rating 10 Overall Comments This is the banjo I should have bought long ago. I would replace it with an identical model asap, but get it at a store with a Superior gig bag, setup, and spikes, and a Barcus-Berry Disc pickup. I love it overall, especially the light weight, open-back size. For all resonating banjos are cracked up to be, light weight is for me. Overall Rating 10

Star Fire Star Fire 6 string banjo submitted 9/1/2008 Submitter duvidel (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased Ebay Year Purchased 2008 Price Paid 150.00 ($US) Sound it has a very full sound, but is rather heavy. I like the fact that it has 6 strings, durable head, but wish overall I had gone with a 5 string to play with tunings. It does not hold its tuning all that well in my humble opinion if tuned to standard guitar tuning. It is fine for strumming or picking, not clawhammer because you can't do drop thumb. I am amazed to even find Star Fire listed here! The instrument has strap hooks which seemed to stay in pretty well, except for 1 time when a strap came off and I had to repair it. Sound Rating 5 Setup The action probably could have been lowered. I did not mess with it. Setup Rating 5 Appearance I screwed it up, I admit it. I tried to put a stencil design on the head. My very bad mistake results in vast depreciation. The sound is still good. Do not monkey with it. It's not worth it. For a cheap way to play guitar on banjo, leave it as is and be happy. This was the only Star Fire I have ever seen. Stick with Galveston, Johnson, or pay for something better. Do not go on the cheap! Learn from my mistake. Have a setup done. Appearance Rating 8 Reliability It will last a long time, very strong neck, body and hardware. It is dependable and the only drawbacks are it may not hold to pitch. Reliability Rating 9 Customer Service I did not deal with the company, I think it is 1 yr warrranty and forgot what vendor I contacted on Ebay. Customer Service 5 Components Everything seemed okay, nothing to really discuss. Components Rating 10 Overall Comments I would not replace this instrument with another 6 string banjo. I would get an Epiphone MB100 5 string and tune it with a capo if I needed a guitar-banjo. I don't hate it, but I wish it were an open back. If I had to get another, I would have paid no more than $120 but it was on auction. Overall Rating 7

Prust tackhead with square peghead submitted 8/31/2008 Submitter boavirett (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased direct from builder Year Purchased 2008 Price Paid 258.00 ($US) Sound frailing /early 3 finger style Classic fretless nylon string sound This banjo is like none I've ever played before.Reminds me of the difference between a classical guitar and a steel string guitar, except that it's fretless. Definitley like comparing apples and oranges (openback vs. resonator) Like it very much. Sound Rating 10 Setup setup (placing the bridge ) was easy but he sent 3 bridges to try out and i liked the lower one best-action closer to neck . Setup Rating 9 Appearance Maple neck with rose wood tailpiece and rosewood stopper inside head Oak rim and brass tackheads holding calf skin top. The joints on the 3 ply rim are barely visible- great woodwork.He placed 12 "fret" markers (rosewood stripes ) flush in the neck, for a minimal extra fee-sets off the maple nicely. Appearance Rating 10 Reliability all hardwood-lasts forever .finish don't know about but seems good. Yes to gigging w/o backup. Reliability Rating 10 Customer Service emailed him from banjobuyer.com and dealt with him directly.Fine easy to deal with a real pleasure.Warranty? don't know. Customer Service 9 Components n/a Components Rating not rated Overall Comments yes If you're looking for a basic banjo fretless civil war era you can't beat the quality or price. Overall Rating 10

Deering Goodtime 2 Classic submitted 8/29/2008 Submitter yumagah (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased DATPro Audio - Ebay Year Purchased 2008 Price Paid 589 ($US) Sound This is the Goodtime with resonator and dark finish. JUst added to their catalog this year, and I have not seen too many around yet. The sound is great. I think it holds its own with any banjo under $1000. I play bluegrass style, but to small audiences, in a small band or alone. So I don't need the punching power of a brass tone ring. The Deering Goodtime family have a rich, mellow sound compared to others in this range. Loud enough for me. Maybe not loud enough for a stage band - the only weakness? Sound Rating 9 Setup All set up and ready to play, except that the strings were shot. Must have been hanging in a busy shop and got tried out a lot. I cleaned up the metal parts a bit. After the warranty ends I will replace the tuners with planetary ones. That will make it look like a more expensive Deering model. Setup Rating 8 Appearance The Goodtime series is plain, but the Classics with dark finish definitely look the best. And the fiddle shaped peghead. I loved the sound of the Goodtime 2 when I played it 2 years ago, but the blond finish kept me from buying. When I heard about the Classic, it was the answer to my quest. Looks simple but elegant. Appearance Rating 8 Reliability Generally the hardware feels real sturdy. The finish is satin semi-gloss, so I don't know how well it will hold up over time. I would feel confident about using it in a show. Deering has a rep. for quality parts. Reliability Rating 8 Customer Service Got one year warranty. Hopefully I won't need it. Company shipped it fast. Customer Service 7 Components The wood and metal parts look great and sturdy. The guitar style tuners are ugly, but they hold the tension good. Swapping them for planetary tuners should really help the looks, but I'm gonna be careful to get quality parts that won't spoil the instrument. Components Rating 7 Overall Comments I shopped around for 2 years, and this was the best deal I saw. I almost got a Gold Tone Bg250f instead, but I think the DG2C tone is even better. The Gold Tone is a nice banjo for the money, probably louder and sharper sounding, and a little better looking. But for my needs, the DG2C has the bet sound. The only better sounding banjos I heard were well over a grand. I'd only spend that kind of money if I were a pro. I love it, but if it were stolen I could live with the Gold Tone instead I guess. Overall Rating 9

Vega Little Wonder 5 String submitted 8/28/2008 Submitter jamie_t123 (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased GC Year Purchased 2008 Price Paid 550 ($US) (bought USED) Sound Nice and plunky. Not the loudest openback I've owned, but nice tone. Sound Rating 8 Setup I set it up and it plays nice.... Setup Rating 8 Appearance There is not much to a little wonder...but the neck is a very nice piece of flame maple... Appearance Rating 8 Reliability OK....satin finish that I might buff out to a semi gloss. Nickle hardware that is servicable... Reliability Rating 8 Customer Service NA Customer Service not rated Components Everything is OK.....Not the top of the line, but very good. Components Rating 7 Overall Comments These things are a litlle pricy new....I think that they are about $2oo a pound or so. You can get a nice Bart Rieter for about the same price. But they are a nice little banjo and if you can find one used for a fair price I think that you would be very happy with it... Overall Rating 8

Deering Calico submitted 8/28/2008 Submitter rvrose (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased ebay Year Purchased 2003 Price Paid 1700.00 ($US) (bought USED) Sound I like the bright sound. I played alot of other brands and like this one best. Sound Rating 10 Setup I haven't touched the setup. Great action - easy to play. Setup Rating 10 Appearance The blond tiger maple and inlays are what initially drew me to this banjo. Appearance Rating 10 Reliability I only wish it was chrome plated since the nickel does tarnish with use. Reliability Rating 10 Customer Service Never had to deal with support. Customer Service 10 Components The neck size and action make this banjo very nice to play. Components Rating 10 Overall Comments I highly recommend for sound, playability and beauty. If stolen - I would get another one - but with chrome plate. I have played Gibsons in shops and never found one that sounded better to me. Overall Rating 10

Nechville Phantom submitted 8/27/2008 Submitter budbennett (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased Turtle Hill Year Purchased 2008 Price Paid $3500- $4,000 ($US) Sound I was looking for a banjo that sounded different from my others and listened to a lot of them. When I heard the Phantom, I decided that one was the one for me. The tone is different, hard to describe- crisp, rich, woody, organic? I don't know a good word to use but it's wonderful. I play mostly classical and new age like music on this banjo and the tone for that is wonderful. I have found that by cranking down the head I can quickly and easily change the tone to more of a bluegrass sound and i have done that and the banjo really cracks and carries. I really like that the banjo is so easily adjustable and versatile. Sound Rating 9 Setup I had a few issues with the banjo when I first got it. I tried to work them out myself but couldn't so I contacted Tom Nechville and Al Price and they were extremely helpful (more about that below). I ended up taking it to a luthier and he fixed it right up for me in a very short time and I have no issues or concerns at all now. New banjos sometimes need a tweak or two, no big deal. Setup Rating 7 Appearance It's gorgeous. Beautiful walnut burl, first rate finish, not a single thing to complain about. I love the look and everyone else does too. Appearance Rating 10 Reliability The only reason I would bring another banjo with me to a job is if I were going to be playing both traditional and classical music. The Phantom is reliable, consistant and I don't foresee any trouble with it. Reliability Rating 10 Customer Service I bought the banjo from Turtle HIll and contacted Dave via phone and internet. Dave is a first rate standup guy and I recommend him to everyone. Dave was approachable by email, answered in a timely manner, was factual and honest, and he even gave me a free capo and hand delivered my banjo to me due to a convenient situation. I spent an hour or so with him and enjoyed it very much and I look forward to buying from him again. When I had a few small issues with my Phantom, I contacted Tom Nechville and Al Price and they were very helpful and informative about my problem. Tom made me a custom height bridge and Al had a new head sent to me. Both did this without asking for money first and trusted my honesty and integrity and THAT is not something you see every day. I completely trust them and applaud them for it. In the end, my issues were cleared up completely and I truly cannot imagine better customer service than what I got from both Turtle Hill and Nechville. Fantastic people and fantastic service! Customer Service 10 Components The look of this banjo is fantastic. The tone is fantastic. The neck plays fantastic. I wouldn't change a thing. Components Rating 10 Overall Comments If this banjo was stolen I would call Dave at Turtle Hill and have him order me another just like it. I love the tone and playability. I suggest if anyone is considering a Phantom to try and hear one in person, they are a little different sounding from other banjos. I for one count that as a big plus too. In my opinion, variety is the spice of life in terms of tone. Overall Rating 10

Enoch Tradesman submitted 8/22/2008 Submitter pernicketylad (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased Zepp Music Year Purchased 2008 Price Paid 1025 ($US) Sound This banjo is great for old-time music.It has a real traditional sound.I only have it for 6 weeks but it got to meet other instruments for the first time last night and it performed brilliantly....it really cut through without being one bit harsh. It had nylgut strings on it when I got it first and I was initially dissappointed in it.I persisted for 5 weeks but it sounded like a plastic basin to me.....tubby in the extreme.The thin 12" pot probably contributes to this aswell.As someone who listens primarily to 20th century recordings this is not the sound I associate with or love about the banjo.It was a bit 19th century-sounding for me (or what I'd imagine 19th century banjos sounded like!) Anyway, the nylgut strings are obviously what I didn't like because when I put the steel ones on it was a different story.It now has a warm sustain and the tone is somewhere between tinny and tubby.....just right really!If a banjo can sound 'friendly' this one does. I should also mention that I've stuffed a sponge under the skin to soften the overtones.This obviously lowers the volume (and I'd prefer to not have to) but it's not absolutely necessary, it's just a preference. It's a half-fretted model and the slides sound great.I think the slides were better with the nylgut strings though. Sound Rating 9 Setup The man at Zepp was very good to deal with but I had requested that the action be lowered.Maybe this was an oversight but it was not done when it arrived! I subsequently had it lowered as it was set very high. Setup Rating 9 Appearance I like the look of this banjo as it is very plain.I'd prefer an ebony veneer on the headstock though and I'm not mad about the fact that the maple rim is painted black (but the maple would probably clash with the cherry neck).The cherry neck on my banjo is really beautiful....really straight grain and a little knot in the wood is a nice feature.The Dobson heel looks great......beautifully crafted neck. The finish seems to be a natural satin finish.It feels great to touch and it looks great.However,I feel a more traditional laquer finish would probably be more durable.The inlay is basic too.....just dots on the fretboard(I think they're MOP).The tuners look well....they're black.....don't know if they're ebony or plastic? This banjo is honest.It'does what it says on the tin'.If you want fancy look elsewhere.The workmanship here has gone into the sound and that's fine by me.It's hard to give it a rating as a result. Appearance Rating 8 Reliability It seems durable but it's early days.The gotoh tuners are a little shaky and I'd fear for the finish in the long term.No problems yet though. Reliability Rating 10 Customer Service I rang Kevin in the early stages of my research.I was initially interested in his M200 model which he told me is no longer in production(although it's still on the website).Anyway, even knowing that I was no longer a potential customer he was a complete gentleman.He was very helpful.This banjo has a lifetime warranty so absolutely full marks here. Customer Service 10 Components I know gotoh tuners have a good name and they look great but as I've mentioned I find them shaky.Planetary tuners would be an idea.I'd probably prefer if the rim and neck were made of the same material.The no-knot tailpiece could also be upgraded and I wouldn't think the brackets and tension hoop are top quality but again its hard to rate this....if the components were better it wouldn't cost $1025! Components Rating 8 Overall Comments For the price I paid I couldn't recommend it enough.It's famous for being a quality,affordable banjo and that's what it is.The exchange rate really helped too!I'm just starting on the fretless so it's perfect for me.If it was stolen tomorrow I'd buy another and I wouldn't have to re-mortgage the house to do it.I'd also be confident the replacement would sound just as good.I got off to a slow start but I'm growing to love this banjo.It doesn't have the punch my Reiter Regent has but it sounds more earthy.I don't prefer either one.They both offer something different.This banjo delivers on sound....the most important thing.Check out the video files on the Zepp Music website for demos....they're great. It's unfair to compare it to more expensive banjos.For the money it's 10/10. Overall Rating 9

Morgan Monroe Cameron submitted 8/21/2008 Submitter Grey Dog (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased http://www.banjoshop.com/ Year Purchased 2008 Price Paid 599 ($US) Sound Nice and mellow, but can still hold a bluegrass edge. I bought this as a lighter, openback travel banjo. The whyte laydie has a nice pluncky (yes, pluncky) sound to it. Sound Rating 8 Setup Needed some minor tweaks, but it was the dead of summer so things could have been loose from the heat/humidity. Out-of-the-box it is more of a clawhammer banjo, but a quick bridge swap gave it enough of a personality change to be scruggsy. Setup Rating 8 Appearance Very nice walnut look and feel. The engraved metal has a cheaper look/feel to it, but given the price that makes sense. Appearance Rating 8 Reliability Solid enough to be considered a travel banjo in my book, so it must be ready for some abuse and bounces. Reliability Rating 9 Customer Service http://www.banjoshop.com/ is absolutely excellent http://www.morganmonroe.com/ I have no dealt with directly Customer Service 10 Components Overall just very solid and reliable Components Rating 9 Overall Comments Yes. I would recommend more for a clawhammer player, but it is definitely sufficient for a bluegrasser as well. Overall Rating 9

Huber Sammy Shelor submitted 8/20/2008 Submitter Yosh (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased from the original owner Year Purchased 2008 Price Paid ($US) (bought USED) Sound I love the "pre-war" sound. Maybe a little plunky. Its not as loud as I had expected. It has a clean sound all the way up the neck. Sound Rating 9 Setup I bought it second hand, six monts old, so I can't comment on the factory setup. The action was a lttle high for my liking with an 11/16 bridge. I replaced it with a 5/8" and still feel its a little high. Setup Rating not rated Appearance It looks like a banjo! I'm not really into appearances - only the sound and playability. I would describe it as having a clean, classic look. Appearance Rating 7 Reliability It seems to be built to last with high quality hardware. It will probably outlive me. Reliability Rating 10 Customer Service Since I bought it second hand I haven't dealt with the customer service. I did email them asking for their recommendation for a pickup, but never got a reply. Customer Service not rated Components It seem like it is constructed with all the best quality parts. Components Rating 10 Overall Comments I would absolutely recommend this banjo. If it was stolen I would cry my heart out. I'm not crazy about the radius neck though only because it takes a little getting used to when I switch to my other banjo. It's not quite as loud as some but has great tone. Overall Rating 9

Stelling goldencross submitted 8/17/2008 Submitter Goldstar Kenny (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased janet davis music Year Purchased 2008 Price Paid 3800 ($US) Sound very loud and very bright it is truly the ultimate banjo Sound Rating 10 Setup set up was perfect accept for the strings they were med-heavy you could probably tow a boat with them so i put daddario j60+ on it and its great Setup Rating 10 Appearance flawless it is presentation flamed maple with beutiful inlays some are gold tinted and a gold tinted truss rod cover stunning banjo Appearance Rating 10 Reliability totally reliable top of the line great finish very sturdy hardware Reliability Rating not rated Customer Service dont have any experience with them yet so i guess its a ten Customer Service not rated Components no cheap parts on this thing it is a masterpeice Components Rating 10 Overall Comments this banjo is far better than any new gibson I have played and any other for that matter the only thing compareable is my good friends staghorn and its a masterpiece also Overall Rating 10

Buckeye Short Scale Maple Neck 12" Pot submitted 8/15/2008 Submitter pauwac (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased Direct from Builder Year Purchased 2008 Price Paid 1,450 ($US) Sound The best sounding old-time banjo I've ever played. Very full tones on the bass string and bright but not piercing on the top strings. A very well-balanced sound. Sound Rating 10 Setup Banjo came nicely set up. Action is medium, I'd say--very easy to play up the neck and everything is in tune. I wouldn't recommend any setup changes. Setup Rating 10 Appearance This banjo is beautiful. Greg is a truly fine woodworker. The curly maple neck in particular is a piece of art--it's simple, elegant, and solid. This banjo has a beautifully designed and expertly applied inlay on the peghead, and Gotoh tuners with black buttons that really work nicely with the overall design. The bridge is really cool, too. Like a good sailboat, airplane, or bicycle, this banjo is a functional work of art. Appearance Rating 10 Reliability This is a very solid and strong banjo which will last for generations. Everything is high quality, from hardware to finish. This is a player's instrument--it's built to last. Reliability Rating 10 Customer Service Here is another area in which Buckeye Banjos shines. Buying an instrument from Greg was a pleasure--he's friendly and really wants you to be satisfied with what you're getting. He throws in a free tee shirt, too. Customer Service 10 Components All components are high quality. No upgrades needed. Components Rating 10 Overall Comments Greg's prices are really good for such high quality instruments. I know there are a lot of really talented builders out there, but I can't see where anyone has anything on Buckeye Banjos, and when you add in the relatively low prices, Greg's banjos can't be beat. It's the best banjo I've ever played. I love it. Overall Rating 10

Morgan-Monroe Riverking submitted 8/15/2008 Submitter aaron p bishop (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased ebay Year Purchased 2007 Price Paid Don't Remember (bought USED) historic exchange rates / currency converter Sound Deep full flathead growl Sound Rating 8 Setup good Setup Rating not rated Appearance simply geogeous Appearance Rating not rated Reliability Reliability Rating 6 Customer Service good Customer Service 7 Components this banjo is awesome Components Rating 9 Overall Comments I own 9 banjos and the riverking is the best.Hand engraved antique brass, ultimate inlay on neck and resnorator.Truly the best and I'll challange anyone on it Overall Rating 10

Yates Ron Stewart submitted 8/15/2008 Submitter stfriesen (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased Warren Yates Year Purchased 2008 Price Paid ($US) Sound This banjo is the Ron Stewart Signature model with the straight grain maple neck. This banjo has that sought after 'prewar' sound. It rings like a bell up the neck and growls like a tiger at the bottom. Each note rings clear with a slight 'zing'. You get the feeling that each note is encapsulated in a bundle of perfectly orchestrated tonal symphony. Its actually hard to describe but extremely pleasing to hear and play. I get this amazement every time I pick it that somehow this instrument just knows how to bring out just the right tones to create a perfectly balanced sound. Volume is exceptionally even up and down the neck. By adjusting your picking style and hand position, you are able to mold the tones in countless ways. This truly is a remarkable instrument. Sound Rating 10 Setup The action was setup just like I like it. The action is not too low and not too high. It actually plays very well, right out of the case. Warren suggested that I check the head tension after shipping. I tweaked it just a bit as the head settled in shipping. This is normal and not a problem. The head is now tuned to about a G# where it has come alive. Setup Rating 10 Appearance This model has what is called a distressed finish. I must say that I had mixed emotions about putting out the money for a new banjo that looks old. However, I can't stop admiring its beauty. It doesn't look worn out, it just looks like it is asking to be played as opposed to simply hanging on a wall to be looked at. Personally, I like to play my banjos. Having said that, this one has a unique beauty that will get people asking questions about it. When the mandolin player in our band saw this banjo, he thought I had picked up a vintage instrument. When I told him that it was only a couple weeks out of the shop, he was amazed. I really like the appearance. The speed neck is simply wonderful to play. The inlay work is beautiful. Very nice interpretation of the flying eagle design. I absolutely love the peg head shape and inlay design. Appearance Rating 10 Reliability I can't see any reliability concerns. The parts are the best. The Keith tuners are without equal. If there would ever be a problem, which I don't think there will be, I know Warren would come through with his awesome personalized service! I have every confidence that this ax will come through in any gig for me. Reliability Rating 10 Customer Service Warren Yates is a pleasure to do business with. You can tell his love for his work and the pride he takes in producing a banjo that stands out from the crowd. With people like Ron Stewart working along side in development and promotion, you can be sure you are dealing with a reputable builder who will go out of his way to make you happy. Customer Service 10 Components This banjo is built to be a working banjo that will last a lifetime. The components are all of the highest quality. Can't see any problems. Components Rating 10 Overall Comments This banjo is a tremendous value. You get that prewar sound without the prewar collectors price. You also get the satisfaction of dealing personally with the builder himself. I ordered this banjo sight unseen, something I would not usually do and had it shipped. I put my trust in Warren and his crew and they did not disappoint me. I now own and play a banjo that is better than any I have ever laid my hands on before. I am proud to play it on any stage and in any venue. Overall Rating 10

Ome Ome Triple X submitted 8/14/2008 Submitter kimmattis123 (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased Gryphon Stringed Insgtruments Year Purchased 2008 Price Paid Don't Remember (bought USED) historic exchange rates / currency converter Sound Sounds Great. I wanted a bluegrass banjo [but that could be played in different styles] this is perfect. Not overly loud but cuts through very well. It has a distinct sound. Not a Gibson or Stelling [ maybe a little Deering type] Sound Rating 9 Setup Setup from Gryphon was very good. Just out of the box it played well. Action low- but loud. I can't think of any changes. Maybe a new bridge. ONE annoying thing is that the 4th string, when bent, goes off the fretboard. It was a used banjo and maybe the bridge is too wide or using Crow spacing. but it plays great -but may not be the orig. bridge. I may have a moon bridge installed. but it sounds so good I hate to mess with it. It did have a 5th sting capo [removed] IF I had known I would have replaced it and not put in the extra spikes. Setup Rating 8 Appearance For a 1976 it was in great shape. All the wood was good, some dings but overall great. Finish was good. Metal parts are shiny and not tarnished or rusty. VERY GOOD shape. Good org. case too. Appearance Rating 9 Reliability Seems like a very good instrument. I haven't even changes the strings yet- and it stays tuned. Great Hardware. No rust, no pitting, shiny chrome parts. A little fading on the Nickel hardware but that gives it the "old Patina thing" Reliability Rating 8 Customer Service Gryphon was very nice. It came when they said it would. They put in additional spikes at no extra charge. They were nice to deal with. I recommend their services. OME is also very good to deal with. Anything they can help with- they do. Customer Service 9 Components I like the 'silverspun-no hole tone ring' -its somewhere between a white lady sound and mastertone. It does sound like the old Bacon silver belle tone rings in their top of the line OLD banjos. It has Presence, not louder, just a sound you can find in a jam situation. It would make a great plectrum banjo and OME still has it in production on their openbacks. Components Rating 9 Overall Comments Yes, this banjo was a steal. I played an ODE a friend of mine restored and this is just as good without the restoration. Considering you are paying about 1k for an import these days this is twice as good at the same price. Overall Rating 9

Stelling Master Flower submitted 8/12/2008 Submitter Grum (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased Janet Davis Year Purchased 2008 Price Paid 3,850 ($US) Sound It just sounds beautiful. Clean, clear, sharp and balanced all the way up the neck. People said Stellings are "loud" but that certainly does not mean coarse or harsh. It plays beautfully at whatever volume you choose to pick it. Sound Rating 10 Setup It was shipped across the planet to Australia from a Northern Summer to a Southern Winter and it was still in tune!!! (well almost) Setup was perfect. Setup Rating 10 Appearance Flawless. I searched it meticulously trying to find some microscopic flaw and failed. It had obviosly been polished within an inch of it's life before packing and posting. Inlay is wonderful. The unstained walnut was a little lighter in colour than I expected but that's because I'm used to Queensland 'walnut' which is a much more chocolate brown. I bought the walnut for the sound, not the colour. Appearance Rating 10 Reliability I've only had it for a fortnight but it seems to exude quality. The plating is deep and brilliant. Reliability Rating 10 Customer Service Very prompt until it got to Australia. The Australian delivery service was slow and frustrating and customs delayed it for days. Customer Service 10 Components Everything seems wonderful, but then you'd expect that on a $5,000 banjo. The TKL case seems to be of top quality as well. Components Rating 10 Overall Comments Janet Davis has genuine sales every month. When I ordered my banjo the Master Flower on the web page disappeared. The price was $3,850 while Banjo.com and FQM and Stelling itself had it listed for $5,000. It feels great. It sounds great. and I think I'm a better player already as a result!!! Overall Rating 10

Deering Sierra submitted 8/9/2008 Submitter sutrx (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased old town school of music Year Purchased 2007 Price Paid 1500 ($US) Sound sound , is great, , i have had it for over a year now and feel qualified to rate it, the sound keeps getting better Sound Rating 9 Setup where i purchased it, the salesman was a banjo player and he set it up and gave me great advice, so i was lucky, a good company and a good salesman Setup Rating 9 Appearance I love it, nothing fancy, nothing special, But it fits me perfectly Appearance Rating 10 Reliability i have had it a year now, so i feel qualified to rate it.,I play it about 5 times a week 1/2 to 1 hr each time. Tuners are still sweet,The tail piece is easy to adjust and easy to change the strings with. I do not have the orginal bridge Reliability Rating 9 Customer Service Company has been easy to respond with , downloading all info from the website. The only thing was getting my deering gold card took a little longer than i thought. but website makes everything quite easy Customer Service 9 Components Love the tuners, Frets are still in good shape and tailpiece is easy to work with , did change the bridge tho, and got a better sound Components Rating 8 Overall Comments I am a 4 yr banjo player and this will be the best banjo i get, will probably purchase a goodtime banjo for traveling so do not have to worry about damage, I wish i would have asked about safety issues when traveling with banjo. Lets be honest i am no ralph stanley, so this banjo will cover all this novice to intermediate player will ever need Overall Rating 9

Bart Reiter Regent submitted 8/7/2008 Submitter pernicketylad (see all reviews from this person) Where Purchased Music Emporium (MA) Year Purchased 2008 Price Paid 1375 ($US) Sound To me this banjo is ideal for old-time music.It's resonant but clear and rich with not too many overtones.While it's not as warm as my 1890s no-namer it's certainly not harsh and there's no need to stick a sock in this banjo!It's a very responsive banjo.....chucks and plucks really come off clear.It can be played loud or soft.It's not to bright sounding but that 5th string really sings...punchy.I can't find fault with the sound of this banjo and sound is the most important thing.It's quite tinny and metallic sounding but it is a banjo after all. Sound Rating 10 Setup The Music Emporium carried out my instructions to the letter by lowering the action by paring the bridge by about 1/16" but I was getting some buzzing on the 3rd string (and on the 2nd and 3rd when in d tuning).I think this is a common problem with the 3rd as it's quite slack.Anyway, I replaced it with an identical new bridge(I think it's a Snuffy Smith) and the 3rd only buzzes slightly when plucked very hard.Anyway,I've no-one to blame for this but myself. I don't like the way the tension hoop is proud.It's about 2/16" higher than the head.I'd prefer if it was flush.The notch cut out of the tension hoop at the scoop is also a minor complaint.I've hit it with my finger a few times.I'm sure I'll learn the hard way! Setup Rating 9 Appearance I love the look of the old Vega Regent models and this is practically identical.It's not flashy but I don't like flashy.The Vega-style headstock is beautifully done and it has the all-important star!I think all the inlay is MOP....the fretboard has dots at the 3rd,5th,7th,10th,12th,15th and 17th.The two-piece Maple neck with ebony strip is a beauty.Ebony heelcap and rosewood rimcap are also nice features.The finish is a traditional satin laquer finish beautifully executed.The planetary tuners are great but I don't like the plasticy look of them...they'd be nice in ebony or ivoroid.I like the look of the bracket band on the old Vega Whyte Ladies but I'm sure that's easier said than done!This Regent model seems to have everything Bart's Whyte Lady has except that ugly Gryphon on the headstock! Appearance Rating 9 Reliability Don't have this banjo long but it seems solid to me.The finish also looks like it would take alot of abuse.This is a heavy piece of machinery.I certainly wouldn't feel like I'd need a back-up.Time will tell how reliable it is but for the moment I'll gve it a ten!The TKL case was also included...that's a major plus. Reliability Rating 10 Customer Service I've never dealt with Bart Reiter but the banjo has a one year warranty.I have to mention Tim at The Music Emporium (MA) here for his patience and professionalism.No question was too annoying!I'm giving The Music Emporium a flawless Ten.Bart Reiter's website is a good resource and the banjo came with a handout on banjo maintenance. Customer Service 10 Components The Planetary tuners hold fast.I'd highly recommend them but as I already mentioned I don't like the plasticy look of them.The Waverly tailpiece seems to do its job.The Whyte Lady tone ring lives up to it's reputation if it is primarily responsible for the sound.I wonder if I replaced the five-star head with a skin head would the sound be warmer but I don't really see any reason to do this as it sounds great as is and I wouldn't want to sacrifice any of that gentle brightness.As I said earlier I'd love if there was a bracket band on it.I think Bart's Deluxe WLs have this feature.Nice thick pot but I think I'd prefer hex-bolts to hold the 24 L-shoes in place. Components Rating 9 Overall Comments For the price this is top notch!I think money won't buy a better sound at any rate.Most of my minor complaints were not surprises to me.......I b